Second Review Forwarded And Dispatched

2026-03-28T20:54:50Z by E2E Test Suite (38s)

Act 1: Setup: Create Issue and Simulated PR

Create a GitHub issue with ludus label, bridge it into a bead, then create a PR that references the bead in its body.

GitHub issue:

{
  "number": 66,
  "title": "E2E review dispatch 1774731253",
  "state": "open",
  "url": "https://api.github.com/repos/b4arena/test-greeter/issues/66",
  "labels": [
    {
      "id": 10371061315,
      "node_id": "LA_kwDORVTOc88AAAACainWQw",
      "url": "https://api.github.com/repos/b4arena/test-greeter/labels/ludus",
      "name": "ludus",
      "color": "aaaaaa",
      "default": false,
      "description": null
    }
  ]
}

bridge (issue → bead)

GitHub Bridge
Bridged GH#66 → ic-82e
  ✓ issues: 1 bead(s) created
    prs: nothing to bridge
    reviews: nothing to bridge
    comments: nothing to bridge

Next:
  ludus info intercom            Ch

Bead state:

{
  "id": "ic-82e",
  "status": "open",
  "title": "GH#66: E2E review dispatch 1774731253",
  "labels": [
    "forge"
  ]
}

PASS. PR #67 created with Intercom: ic-82e

Act 2: First CHANGES_REQUESTED Review

Post first review, run bridge, verify bead comment.

bridge (first review)

GitHub Bridge
Forwarded PR#67 review → ic-82e
    issues: nothing to bridge
    prs: nothing to bridge
  ✓ reviews: 1 bead(s) created
    comments: nothing to bridge

Next:
  ludus info intercom

PASS. Bridge comments after first review: 1 (expected 1)

Act 3: Second Review (Previously Dropped)

Post a second review. Before the fix, the bridge silently dropped all reviews after the first. This act verifies the fix.

bridge (second review)

GitHub Bridge
Forwarded PR#67 review → ic-82e
    issues: nothing to bridge
    prs: nothing to bridge
  ✓ reviews: 1 bead(s) created
    comments: nothing to bridge

Next:
  ludus info intercom

PASS. Bridge comments after second review: 2 (expected 2)

Act 4: Verify Agent Received Direct Notification

The bridge should have dispatched a non-blocking notification to the owning agent via gateway call chat.send.

FAIL. Bead has 0 review comments (expected ≥2)

Act 5: Cleanup

PASS. PR and issue closed.

Summary

Act	Result	Summary
1	PASS	PR #67 created with Intercom: ic-82e
2	PASS	Bridge comments after first review: 1 (expected 1)
3	PASS	Bridge comments after second review: 2 (expected 2)
4	FAIL	Bead has 0 review comments (expected ≥2)
5	PASS	PR and issue closed.