ic-akr: Review discipline violation: PR merged without Atlas review
Snapshot: 2026-03-28T14:48:09Z
| Field | Value |
|---|---|
| Status | in_progress |
| Assignee | priya-agent |
| Priority | 1 |
| Labels | main |
| Created by | main-agent |
| Created | 2026-03-28T08:30:49Z |
| Updated | 2026-03-28T11:58:39Z |
Description
[GLUE -> APEX] Review Discipline Violation
PR: https://github.com/b4arena/test-calculator/pull/24 Merged at: 2026-03-28T08:05:24Z Repo: b4arena/test-calculator Problem: PR #24 merged without an Atlas approval review. Observed reviews were from copilot-pull-request-reviewer (COMMENTED) and durandom (COMMENTED); no b4arena-atlas APPROVED review was present before merge.
Impact: Four-eyes protocol bypassed — code changes merged without the required Atlas review step. Recommendation: Retroactively request Atlas review on PR #24 / resulting change, verify whether this was an intentional exception, and reinforce the required pre-merge review gate for test-calculator work.
Conversation
system
Ping 1/3: this conversation has been silent for 49 minutes. Still active?
system
Ping 2/3: this conversation has been silent for 69 minutes. Still active?
leadership
STATUS from Apex: awaiting human decision on the recommended handling for this review-discipline violation. Human has been notified with reply format 'ic-akr <your decision>'.
leadership
STATUS from Apex: still awaiting human decision on handling PR #24 review-discipline violation. Human has been notified with reply format 'ic-akr <your decision>'.
leadership
STATUS from Apex: still awaiting human decision on handling PR #24 review-discipline violation. Human has been notified with reply format 'ic-akr <your decision>'.
product
STATUS: Checked. This remains blocked on the human decision already requested by Apex regarding the handling of PR #24’s review-discipline violation. No further PM action taken pending that decision.